Arab news at a glance

“Let them return to Morocco!” Morocco’s UN ambassador Omar Hilale confronted his Algerian counterpart, Amar Bendjama, at the Security Council on Friday, October 30. In an unusually direct exchange following Russia’s veto of a US-backed resolution on Western Sahara, the two diplomats traded accusations over Sahrawi self-determination, refugee camps in Algeria and Palestine.

The confrontation followed the rejection of a US proposal that would have made Morocco’s autonomy plan the sole basis for negotiations. The draft secured 11 votes in the 15-member Council but was defeated by a Russian veto. A rival Russian proposal to extend the mandate of the UN mission in Western Sahara, MINURSO, also failed.

Bendjama spoke first, thanking Moscow for opposing the American proposal before accusing Washington of attempting to “legalise a fait accompli” by endorsing Moroccan sovereignty over the territory.

“Who is afraid of democracy? Who is afraid of the ballot?” the Algerian ambassador asked, defending the Sahrawis’ right to determine their own future, including the option of independence.

He argued that the US proposal effectively settled the outcome of negotiations before they had even begun.

“Negotiations must be a patient process towards a solution, towards peace, not a means of imposing a predetermined conclusion,” he said.

“What gives you the right?” Hilale challenges Algeria

Bendjama’s remarks prompted a response that Hilale said he had not planned to deliver.

“I wasn’t prepared, and I had no intention of speaking,” the Moroccan ambassador said, noting that previous votes on Western Sahara had generally passed without direct exchanges between the two countries’ representatives.

Hilale then challenged Algeria’s insistence that it was not a party to the conflict, despite its longstanding support for the Polisario Front.

“You lecture the Security Council? You lecture its members […] What gives you the right?” he asked Bendjama.

He described the Algerian statement as a “veritable indictment” of the Security Council and the countries that had supported the US draft.

“We are fed up with your lectures about history and international law,” Hilale said, dismissing his counterpart’s arguments as “pompous” and lacking legal substance.

Refugee camps become the focus of the dispute

The exchange intensified over the Sahrawi refugee camps near Tindouf in southwestern Algeria.

Bendjama condemned reductions in international food assistance, describing them as “shameless blackmail through starvation”. He also warned against what he called the risk of “forced displacement” being presented as a solution for the refugees.

Hilale countered by accusing Algeria of preventing the UN refugee agency, UNHCR, from formally registering the camps’ residents.

“Let the High Commissioner carry out the registration and identification,” he said, claiming that Malians and Algerians were also living in the camps.

“If there are one million people, Morocco will accept that figure,” he added, arguing that registration was necessary to establish how many people required humanitarian assistance.

The Moroccan ambassador also accused Algerian authorities of restricting refugees’ freedom of movement and making their return conditional on a political settlement.

“Let them return to Morocco, let them return to the Sahara, let them go to Spain or Europe or Africa, but do not deprive them of that freedom,” Hilale declared.

He accused Algiers of keeping the refugees “hostage to Algeria’s political agenda” and to an armed separatist movement.

Palestine sparks another confrontation

The two diplomats also clashed over Palestine.

Bendjama denounced what he described as a “shameful deal” struck at the expense of Palestinians, drawing a parallel between the Palestinian question and Western Sahara.

Hilale rejected the comparison, calling it “shameful”.

“At least in Morocco, there have been, and still are, demonstrations every week in support of the Palestinian people. In Algeria, such demonstrations are banned,” he said.

Briefly interrupted during his remarks, Hilale turned to his counterpart and replied: “I let you speak,” before continuing.

Towards the end of his statement, Hilale thanked the countries that had backed the American resolution, acknowledging that “Morocco made enormous concessions” to reach a draft it had hoped would be acceptable to all sides.

When offered a final opportunity to respond, Bendjama declined to continue the exchange.

“I have much more to say, but I will refrain out of respect for this Council,” he said.

The confrontation ended as MINURSO’s mandate approached its expiry on Saturday, October 31, after 35 years of UN presence in Western Sahara, with no extension adopted by the Security Council.